Theatre Review: ‘Head Over Heels’ in Love with The Go-Go’s Musical

Head Over Heels

What do obscure Elizabethan poetry, a superstar drag queen, and the music of The Go-Go’s have in common? At first glance, not a damn thing. Yet when these elements are combined in the new Broadway musical Head Over Heels, the result is a wacky, heartwarming explosion of fun.


My connection to this musical is multi-layered, and probably not very fascinating to anyone but me — but I’m going to tell you about it anyway. I was attending Dad 2.0 Summit (as I do every year), where I met that rarest and most fabulous of creatures, a fellow gay dad blogger. I thought I knew them all, so was excited to make the acquaintance of Mr. Gavin Lodge. In addition to being a father, a husband and a blogger, Gavin mentioned that he was an actor and that he’d been cast as a standby in a new Broadway musical. My interest was peaked.

He described the show’s story as taken from an obscure, Elizabethan text, and would be performed largely in iambic pentameter. (!) He told me it was called Head Over Heels, and would feature the music of The Go-Go’s. (!!) He said it would also include the first trans actor to originate a role on Broadway. (!!!) I texted Papa about the show and that it would be in previews in New York starting in June and that we were going to get tickets. It was not a question.

When I got home from the conference, my research uncovered that the trans actor Gavin referenced was Peppermint — my absolute favorite contestant from season 9 of RuPaul’s RuPaul’s Drag Race. Tickets were snatched, post-haste.


The text is loosely based on Sir Phillip Sidney’s 16th-century poem The Countess of Pembroke’s Arcadia. What this mostly means is that everyone talks like Kenneth Branagh and that there are lots of sex- and gender-related shenanigans. While the Elizabethan English might be a deterrent for some, the stunning visuals and song lyrics will keep you up to speed. A peppering of contemporary vernacular was also used to hilarious effect.

The Go-Go’s biggest hits (“Our Lips Are Sealed,” “Vacation,” “We Got the Beat,” etc.) fit seamlessly into the story. The show also featured two songs from lead singer Belinda Carlisle, as well as several deep cuts from the 1980s girl group’s catalog. The lesser-known songs were a surprisingly nice touch — I found myself listening more closely when I didn’t have lyrics to sing along with.

As for the cast, it was a thrill seeing Peppermint make her stage debut as the fabulously gender-bending Pythio. One of my favorite musical numbers was her hippy-trippy “Vision of Nowness.” And of course her costumes were the most.

Head Over Heels

Head Over Heels

While the entire company is stellar, Rachel York (as Queen Gynecia) and Bonnie Milligan were standouts. I was particularly drawn to Milligan’s Princess Pamela was particularly , who owned her bawdy, buxom beauty. She filled every scene (a saucy poetry reading) and song (the hilariously manic “How Much More”) she was in. And kudos to the writers for not including a single fat joke in the entire show.

Head Over Heels

Head Over Heels


Undoubtedly kids will enjoy the music, dancing, costumes and sets. The dialog will likely go over the heads of elementary school children, and there’s one scene of simulated sex behind a scrim that may raise a few questions. I don’t recall any profanity, and any violence is minimal and mimed for the stage. Personally, my nearly nine-year-old has come a long way since his first live theatre experience, and I think he’d be just fine seeing Head Over Heels.


Amidst Head Over Heels‘ wondrous flurry of color, movement and wit, a message of inclusiveness shone the brightest. Woven into the typical-for-its-time gender-swapping, sexual secrets and mistaken identity was a timely theme of acceptance. Same-sex and pansexual love, gender fluidity, and even pronoun preference were touched on. While these might be hot-button issues for some, they were presented in a non-preachy, organic way that left the audience in tears of both laughter and hope.

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Encore Performance

Several months into the run, Gavin had the opportunity to play King Basilius on stage, so I jumped at the chance to see the show again. Gavin fit right in with the rest of the cast for another fabulous performance!

Head Over Heels

Head Over Heels

Head Over Heels

Many, many thanks to Gavin for the tickets, the tour, and the introductions! <virtual standing ovation> Want to check out the show yourself? Get tickets here and check out the just-released soundtrack here!

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.